Persnickety Jewelry and Gifts

08/29/2026

Bogg-tastic News, Folks! 🎉 Your wait is over! Bogg toppers are back in stock and better than ever! 👀 We've got Bitty, Baby, Half Original, and Original Toppers, because who doesn't need options? 😉
Instore only, so don't be a party pooper - grab those new plaid and spooky styles for fall, and don't even get me started on the adorable Bits! 😉
Shop Persnickety Today
📍1003 E Oak st, Arcadia FL 34266
Saturdays: 9:00am-4:00pm
(863) 491-1458

08/29/2026

08/29/2026

“August slipped away into a moment in time…” 💚🎶

But this August birthstone beauty? That’s one you’ll want to keep.

Peridot + 14kt yellow gold + diamonds = a little piece of August magic. ✨

08/28/2026

🍂🌹 A little fall sunshine, wrapped in roses! 🌹🍂

Nothing says fall is in the air quite like a beautiful bouquet paired with all the warm, cozy feelings of the season. Our vibrant coral roses are nestled among delicate white blooms and lush greenery for an arrangement that feels both romantic and perfectly autumn-inspired. 🤎

Whether you’re sending a little love, celebrating someone special, or simply bringing a touch of fall beauty into your home, this bouquet is ready to make someone’s day a little brighter. 🍁✨

Because sometimes the best part of fall isn’t the pumpkin spice… it’s the flowers. 🌹🍂
📍Persnickety Jewelry and Gifts | 1003 E Oak st, Arcadia FL 34266
(863) 491-1458
www.persnicketyflowers.com

08/28/2026

I dream of Peridot 💚
Strength, Protection, Renewal, and Positivity are only a few representations of this beautiful 'Gem of the Sun', said to bring a sense of balance and harmony to those who wear it. We take great care in selecting only the best in fine jewelry to make sure that your gemstones sparkle with brilliance and your diamonds shine with clarity, so you can cherish your Peridot jewelry for years to come.
From elegant necklaces to stunning earrings, our Peridot pieces are designed to make a statement and inspire confidence. Whether you're looking to treat yourself or gift someone special, our Peridot jewelry is the perfect choice to spread love and positivity.
Shop Today at
📍1003 E Oak st, Arcadia FL 34266
OPEN: Mon-Fri 9am-5:30pm, Sat 9am-4pm
(863) 491-1458

08/27/2026

We are beyond thrilled to announce that Persnickety Jewelry and Gifts has been voted Best of Florida for 2026!!! 🎉 This incredible honor is a testament to the hard work and dedication of our teams in our Arcadia and Punta Gorda locations - and we of course couldn't have done it without the support of our amazing customers! 🙏
A huge thank you to everyone who took the time to vote for us - your loyalty and trust mean the world to us! We're so grateful to have the opportunity to serve our wonderful communities and can't wait to continue providing you with the best jewelry and gifts in the state.
And now, the countdown begins... waiting for those shiny new badges to arrive so we can proudly display them on our doors! 🏆💫 We're honored, we're humbled, and we're so excited for what the future holds! 🎉
📍1003 E Oak St, Arcadia FL 34266
📍258 W. Marion Ave, Punta Gorda FL 33950
📍(COMING SOON) 17150 Concourse Way - Building A-102, Babcock Ranch 33982

08/27/2026

🎉Best of Florida results!!!!🎉

08/27/2026

🩷🩷🩷🐶🐶🐶

There is a slight possibility that I may have forgotten to post a featured arrangement today. As an apology i present to you 🥁🥁🥁
A PUPPY MADE OF CARNATION FLOWERS!! 🩷😮🎉
In a basket, holding a little sign 🩷
I hope it makes up for my lateness 😅
But hey! We open at 9am tomorrow at Persnickety Jewelry and Gifts so you have plenty of time to place an order for tomorrow's delivery!
Shop online at www.persnicketyflowers.com
Or give us a ring in the morning at (863) 491-1458

08/26/2026

When the social media girl runs out of ideas… so naturally, we stare into the dressing room and call it ✨content✨ 😂👗🛍️

08/26/2026

It's our Biggest What's New Wednesday Yet! 8/26
In case you missed the news - Persnickety is coming to B-Street in Babcock Ranch!
We are so excited to be starting this new chapter and we've gotten a few questions since making the announcement ❤
👀 Where will you be located? - 17150 Concourse Way - Building A-102 on B Street!
🤔 When are you Opening? – We’re still heavily under construction, but we’re planning for a Winter 2026 Opening, more details to come soon in the weeks ahead.
🫢 Are you closing the Arcadia or Punta Gorda stores? – No, Nope and No Way! Our Arcadia store is our main hub and where we started our business over 22 years ago. Downtown Punta Gorda is our second home, and we don’t plan on leaving any time soon!
💰 Are you hiring? – Not yet, but we will be posting soon for hiring information. What we can say is that initial training will be done in our Arcadia or Punta Gorda locations so that you can get a feel for our products and get to know our customers too!
🛍 What will you sell? – Persnickety in Babcock Ranch is going to closely resemble our Punta Gorda Location, but unfortunately without the chocolates as we start out. We’re going to be stocking this store FULL of your favorite brands: Kendra Scott, Brighton, Bogg Bags, Dune Jewelry (with locally and ethically sourced sand and natural elements from the area), Spartina, and Simply Southern just to name a few – and more to come!
None of this would be possible without our incredible staff, our amazing customers, and the support of our loved ones. Thank you to everyone - whether you started shopping with us 22 years ago, or if you just discovered us today.
🍍Have a Wonderful Wednesday🍍 Love - Angie and all of us at Persnickety💎