Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse

Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse We are a family run restaurant who take pride in all we create. Hand cut PRIME steaks fresh seafood & Farm to table is our goal! Support local!

LOCAL Farm Fresh homemade specials that will leave you in “awe”
Relax in a very casual and stunning atmosphere. Nick Stoner Inn is a Seafood & Steakhouse specializing in fresh seafood and in house hand cut steaks grilled and cooked to perfection. We offer unique creative dishes in a wide range of seafood, steak and handheld foods. Our restaurant will be sure to satisfy everyone’s taste buds! We ha

ve a wide range of locally craft beer on tap (19) craft liquor, and local NY wines from vineyard’s in the Finger Lakes! If your looking for the perfect venue to host any event, wedding, bridal jack and Jill party, etc.... we have the most beautiful venue and unlimited options and can create “together” the most perfect menu for your special day......so give us a call.

08/09/2026

Tomorrow breakfast @ 9am and Terry Mojo Johnson will be here! 1-3pm

Please Help our good family friends, son Derek while he waits for his 3rd kidney transplant at 29 years old! This family...
08/06/2026

Please Help our good family friends, son Derek while he waits for his 3rd kidney transplant at 29 years old! This family is so compassionate to others while never asking for anything in return! Thoughts & Prayers

This is Derek. He is currently waiting for his 3rd kidney transplant. Since he has had… Amber Ward needs your support for Donation for our good friend Derek

Good morning all. We have a summer weekend full of delicious favorites, cold drinks 🍸 scrumptious appetizers and more! S...
08/06/2026

Good morning all. We have a summer weekend full of delicious favorites, cold drinks 🍸 scrumptious appetizers and more!

Sunday funday we will have the legendary TERRY MOJO Johnson here playing his own homemade guitar’s 🎸
He’s been a part of the NSI family since we open our doors almost 10 years ago!

The Monster 50ounce plus…..TOMAHAWK steak 🥩 is BACK again……hand Cut in house by Charlie!

Summer hours…..

Thursday 2pm - 8pm
Friday 12-8pm
Saturday 11-8pm
Sunday BREAKFAST 9am TERRY MOJO Johnson will be here 1-3pm.
9am - 4pm kitchen and bar open.

Summer time weekend specials….

⭐ Bar special…… local Farm fresh grilled chicken breast BLT sandwich. {Roswell family farms • and Dolgville Bread Basket}

~ Surf & turf tacos 🌮 made with Rebecca’s •homemade garlic and herb 🪴 tortillas.

Entree’s…….

~Tomahawk pork chop (starting Friday) charbroiled to perfection over red skinned mashed potato’s drizzled with our delicious signature mushroom 🍄‍🟫 gravy {Gluten Free}

~ NEW popular lobster 🦞 dish…..
Fresh lobster with fresh made pasta (using live lobsters prepared in house)
with Morgie’s delicious and creamy vodka sauce. Amazing dish!

~ NSI SIGNATURE Steak & Seafood special…. The ultimate celebration entree! THE WOW Factor!
Your choice Steak 🥩 topped w/ bacon wrapped scallops, colossal shrimp, 12-14oz lobster 🦞 tail and your choice side, salad and a loaf of DBB bread 🍞 {Gluten Free}

~ Local Farm fresh chicken breast, and grilled shrimp with our daughter Morgan’s delicious VODKA sauce over zoodles/zucchini noodles {Gluten Free} or fresh pasta

~ Charlie’s loaded Seafood chowder {Gluten Free}
~ Crab 🦀 cakes are back. Made with real crabmeat {Gluten Free}

~Grilled Salmon BLACKENED or……drizzled with our maple bourbon sauce, and served with grilled zucchini. {Gluten free}

🥩 Steaks ….. in house cut by Charlie.
Filet
NY Strip
Ribeye
Tomahawk Pork Chop from local family farm.
50ounce plus TOMAHAWK STEAK 🥩

Apps…..
12-14 oz Lobster 🦞 tail (GF)
Fresh Oysters 🦪 (GF)
Bacon wrapped scallops(GF)
Colossal shrimp 🍤 cocktail(GF)
Little neck Clams (GF) & wine steamers
NSI Poutine (GF)
Ahi tuna app. (GF)
Real crabmeat…..Crab cake 🦀 stuffed mushrooms 🍄‍🟫 (GF)
FO Soup
Charlie’s loaded seafood chowder (GF)

Regular menu always!
Lighter side menu and bar menu all weekend long!

ALWAYS……Local Farm fresh Burgers 🍔
Tacos 🌮 chicken, steak, shrimp, or ahi tuna
Wings, soup, chowder and more!

Sunday funday is all about breakfast this weeken

1810 state hwy 10 caroga lake ny
Call 📞 518-835-8039 during business hours
Or message the page for reservations

Good morning NSI family we are open today at 11am till 8pm and tomorrow is Sunday morning Breakfast here at NSI @ 9am ti...
08/01/2026

Good morning NSI family we are open today at 11am till 8pm and tomorrow is Sunday morning Breakfast here at NSI @ 9am till 12pm.
Lunch, dinner and specials starting at 12-4pm

We are a family run business, it’s summer and very busy during prime dinning hours, please be patient and kind to our front of the house family who are trying their best to serve you. Family owned and run and doing the best that we can. ♥️ thank you and have a blessed weekend.

50 ounce plus TOMAHAWK steaks, seafood, burgers 🍔 wings and much more! We hope to see you.

1810 state hwy 10 caroga lake NY
518-835- 8039
Or visit our page and leave a message for table reservations.

PS…. We sold out of our lobster 🦞 pasta dish. Thank you 🙏

Your all crazy! 🤪 Loving the TOMAHAWK special!
07/31/2026

Your all crazy! 🤪
Loving the TOMAHAWK special!

Good morning all. We have a summer weekend full of delicious favorites, cold drinks 🍸 scrumptious appetizers and more! T...
07/30/2026

Good morning all. We have a summer weekend full of delicious favorites, cold drinks 🍸 scrumptious appetizers and more!

The Monster 50ounce plus…..TOMAHAWK steak 🥩 is BACK! Cut in house by Charlie! Starting Friday!

We also have local farm fresh DUCK breast from Tylutki farm for a special this week…… and Tomahawk pork chops grilled to perfection and so juicy and tender!

Summer hours…..

Thursday 12-8pm
Friday 12-8pm
Saturday 11-8pm
Sunday 9-4pm breakfast (9-11am) lunch and dinner served from 12-4pm

Summer time weekend specials….

⭐ Bar special…… local Farm fresh grilled chicken breast BLT sandwich. {Roswell family farms • and Dolgville Bread Basket}

~ Surf & turf tacos 🌮 made with Rebecca’s •homemade garlic and herb 🪴 tortillas.

Entree’s…….

~ DUCK breast (locally sourced and farm fresh from Tylutki family farm) cooked to absolute perfection……
served with a delectable orange 🍊 cherry 🍒 glaze, roasted carrots 🥕 and red skinned mashed potato’s with Charlie’s most delicious Au jus sauce, making this an unforgettable meal!

~Tomahawk pork chop (starting Friday) charbroiled to perfection over red skinned mashed potato’s drizzled with our delicious signature mushroom 🍄‍🟫 gravy {Gluten Free}

~ NEW popular lobster 🦞 dish…..
Fresh lobster pappardelle pasta (using live lobsters prepared in house)
with Morgie’s delicious and creamy vodka sauce. Amazing dish!

~ NSI SIGNATURE Steak & Seafood special…. The ultimate celebration entree! THE WOW Factor!
Your choice Steak 🥩 topped w/ bacon wrapped scallops, colossal shrimp, 12-14oz lobster 🦞 tail and your choice side, salad and a loaf of DBB bread 🍞 {Gluten Free}

~ Local Farm fresh chicken breast, and grilled shrimp with our daughter Morgan’s delicious VODKA sauce over zoodles/zucchini noodles {Gluten Free} or fresh pasta

~ Charlie’s loaded Seafood chowder {Gluten Free}
~ Crab 🦀 cakes are back. Made with real crabmeat {Gluten Free}

~ Pan seared Scallop & shrimp scampi style entree over fresh pasta or rice…. Have it with our delicious house Alfredo or vodka sauce! Yum 😋

~Grilled Salmon BLACKENED or……drizzled with our maple bourbon sauce, and served with grilled zucchini. {Gluten free}

🥩 Steaks ….. in house cut by Charlie.
Filet
NY Strip
Ribeye
Tomahawk Pork Chop from local family farm.
50ounce plus TOMAHAWK STEAK 🥩

Apps…..
12-14 oz Lobster 🦞 tail (GF)
Fresh Oysters 🦪 (GF)
Bacon wrapped scallops(GF)
Colossal shrimp 🍤 cocktail(GF)
Little neck Clams (GF) & wine steamers
NSI Poutine (GF)
Ahi tuna app. (GF)
Real crabmeat…..Crab cake 🦀 stuffed mushrooms 🍄‍🟫 (GF)
FO Soup
Charlie’s loaded seafood chowder (GF)

Regular menu always!
Lighter side menu and bar menu all weekend long!

ALWAYS……Local Farm fresh Burgers 🍔
Tacos 🌮 chicken, steak, shrimp, or ahi tuna
Wings, soup, chowder and more!

Sunday funday is all about breakfast this weekend and regular menu.

1810 state hwy 10 caroga lake ny
Call 📞 518-835-8039 during business hours
Or message the page for reservations

Wow we love the support! Thanks 🙏 Who wants us to continue to serve breakfast on Sundays till September?
07/26/2026

Wow we love the support! Thanks 🙏
Who wants us to continue to serve breakfast on Sundays till September?

Breakfast is served in Caroga Lake NY!
07/26/2026

Breakfast is served in Caroga Lake NY!

Address

1810 State Highway 10
Caroga Lake, NY
12032

Opening Hours

Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 12pm - 8pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share