07/15/2026
At first glance, these two brooches look similar enough to be designed and constructed by the same maker. But if you look closer, there are subtle differences which makes me doubt that.
For example the brooch on the top has rounded prongs while the bottom has squared edge prongs holding the stones in place. The red stones look visually similar. The clear stones on the top are faceted differently and a slightly grayer shade than the lower one.
Check out the pictures of the backs to see other differences! Both have some foiled stones and are soldered but the components holding the stones are different!
I have no opinion regarding which is older or better constructed. Both are clearly vintage and would have been hand constructed.
When buying "vintage" jewelry, looking for clues like these will help you know if what you are looking at is true vintage.