Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN

Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN Improve your game with NEW or SLIGHTLY USED fitness and sports equipment from PLAY IT AGAIN SPORTS Fishers! We sell High-Quality USED sporting goods!

We sell NEW sporting goods and fitness equipment from major brand name manufacturers. We’ll buy your slightly USED GEAR from you. You can also trade in that USED GEAR for top quality, NEW or other slightly used athletic gear. Great prices on NEW and used treadmills, home gyms, weights, and the hottest new elliptical trainers and exercise bikes! Top-quality Proline golf equipment, lacrosse, hockey

, baseball, Adidas soccer, football, and more. Before you buy any new or used sports gear, visit PLAY IT AGAIN SPORTS FISHERS! We will meet or beat any competitor's (Online Too!) price on any current model item in stock.

Getting paid for quality used hockey gear is a pro move. Bring in your gear and give it a new life on the ice! 💰🏒 ...
08/31/2026

Getting paid for quality used hockey gear is a pro move. Bring in your gear and give it a new life on the ice! 💰🏒

Make a power play at Play It Again Sports! Bring in your hockey gear and get paid for quality used sticks, pads and more...
08/30/2026

Make a power play at Play It Again Sports! Bring in your hockey gear and get paid for quality used sticks, pads and more.

In partnership with CCM, we’re now buying quality used hockey gear! Earn cash for helmets, sticks, gloves and more.
08/29/2026

In partnership with CCM, we’re now buying quality used hockey gear! Earn cash for helmets, sticks, gloves and more.

Get paid for hockey gear at Play It Again Sports! We’re buying quality used sticks, gloves, helmets and more.
08/28/2026

Get paid for hockey gear at Play It Again Sports! We’re buying quality used sticks, gloves, helmets and more.

Turn your passion for sports into a career. Join the Play It Again Sports team. Apply today!
08/27/2026

Turn your passion for sports into a career. Join the Play It Again Sports team. Apply today!

Don't let unused gear sit in the garage. ♻️ Bring in quality-used sports equipment and turn it into CASH or trade it tow...
08/18/2026

Don't let unused gear sit in the garage. ♻️ Bring in quality-used sports equipment and turn it into CASH or trade it toward the gear you need for the next season! We buy, sell and trade all sports all year with no appointments needed!

08/17/2026

💪 Get paid for your benches, weights, and more! Trade in, or Sell your gear at Play It Again Sports and score cash on the spot! No appointments needed for most items!

We help athletes and families stay active with affordable gear sourced right from the community. Rawlings Sportin...
08/16/2026

We help athletes and families stay active with affordable gear sourced right from the community.
Rawlings Sporting Goods Easton Baseball

08/15/2026

Season ready without the retail prices ⚾ Find quality used baseball and softball gear for less at Play It Again Sports.
Rawlings Sporting Goods Easton Baseball

Summer sports winding down? Trade in the gear you're finished using and turn it into CASH. It's a great way to make room...
08/14/2026

Summer sports winding down? Trade in the gear you're finished using and turn it into CASH. It's a great way to make room and save on what's next.

Rawlings Sporting Goods Easton Baseball

Address

11681 Olio Road
Fishers, IN
46037

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Play It Again Sports - Fishers, IN:

Shortcuts

Share

Category