05/21/2026
Today I was able to work on an incredibly cool project from the collection of Kevin Canberg. This Forage Cap was worn by Isaac H. Selner during his service with the nine month 128th Pennsylvania and is identified by Selner on the visor as being the cap that he wore at Antietam. It is one of those few instances where I hold no skepticism as to the authenticity as there are other extant 128th caps (with ventilators) as well as images this precise style being worn by other members of the regiment around this time (see MOH recipient Ignatz Gresser).
This cap bore witness to the regiments confusing and costly first battle at Antietam. Mustering in exactly one month and one day before this, the regiment had not mastered the intricacies of Battalion Drill and this, along with death of Colonel Samuel Croasdale at the opening of the fighting, contributed heavily to their clunky entrance into the fighting in and around the East Woods and Miller’s Cornfield. By the end of the fighting, the 128th lost a total of 34 killed and 85 wounded.
The cap itself appears to be the work of George Hoff & Company judging by the visor shape, lack of reeds, turned sweatband and overall pattern. The exposed pasteboard reveals newsprint constituting one of the layers of paper used. As the various ads list “South Street,” “Walnut,” “Chestnut” and other Philadelphia streets, it’s pretty cool to be able to work on a cap that likely has not revisited the city since the war.
Being from Bucks County where Selner’s company was from and making caps in the very neighborhood where this cap was made certainly added significant weight in helping to ensure that this cap will be around for generations to come.