Mystery Spot Antiques

Mystery Spot Antiques The Catskills' shrine to clutter in Phoenicia NY. BIG SALE select items. Open 11-5 Sat/Sun 2025 Open Memorial Day and every Monday thereafter.

This Catskills' "shrine to clutter" occupies seven packed-to-the-rafters rooms in a former 1800's Main Street hotel in Phoenicia, NY in the Catskill Mountains. Mystery Spot Antiques is home to an amazing array of hand-picked vintage clothing, breakables, antiquarian art books, Rusticalia, mid-century lighting, tons of used records and found objects you won't find elsewhere, as well as anything els

e that catches artist/proprietress Laura Levine's honed eye. She regularly brings in antique and vintage treasures, armfuls of killer estate-fresh vintage clothing, and stacks of vintage vinyl from cool collections. For eighteen seasons the Mystery Spot odditorium has been the "must-see" destination for treasure hunters, thrifters, fashionistas, record diggers, tourists, musicians, curiosity seekers, fashion designers, prop stylists, and even a famous face or two. Even when the shop is not open, customers are welcome to dig through the dollar record bins and famous "Yard Sale in a Box" on the front porch, with an honor box/money drop at your service. Homer & Langley's Mystery Spot Antiques

72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464

(845) 688-7868

2019 Spring schedule: open Saturdays 11 - 6, Sundays 11 - 5 + holidays. Starting in late June we'll be open Thurs - Mon all summer-long through Labor Day. Please "like" this page, follow us on Instagram or sign up for our mailing list and you'll be the first to know about upcoming sales and announcements. http://www.mysteryspotantiques.com (website)

http://www.mysteryspotvintage.com (blog)

(Instagram)

email: [email protected]

Our YARD SALE IN A BOX on the front porch has fresh treasures!
11/21/2025

Our YARD SALE IN A BOX on the front porch has fresh treasures!

Think Halloween! 🎃Even though the shop is hibernating, our FRONT PORCH is packed with bargains 24/7. Check out our $5. c...
10/23/2025

Think Halloween! 🎃

Even though the shop is hibernating, our FRONT PORCH is packed with bargains 24/7. Check out our $5. clothing rack for pieces with Halloween potential. Honor system drop box. Also fresh dollar records.

Hibernating.
10/21/2025

Hibernating.

We’re now hibernating for the season but here’s a happy customer from earlier today to remind you to keep an eye on this...
10/19/2025

We’re now hibernating for the season but here’s a happy customer from earlier today to remind you to keep an eye on this page for pop-up surprises.

Score! Our favorite vintage psychedelic Peter Max bedspread is going home with a happy customer today! Just look at thos...
10/19/2025

Score! Our favorite vintage psychedelic Peter Max bedspread is going home with a happy customer today! Just look at those colors. At half price no less!

📸:DG

We love the enchanting Martin Denny and so are you! Let’s listen as he plays us out on our last day of the season before...
10/19/2025

We love the enchanting Martin Denny and so are you! Let’s listen as he plays us out on our last day of the season before we hibernate….

Drop by today between 11-5 for your last chance at our MEGA SALE.

📸:DG

MYSTERY SPOT NEWS:This weekend (Oct. 18/19) is our last for the season. (Then we hibernate).Our 20%-50% SALE is extended...
10/15/2025

MYSTERY SPOT NEWS:

This weekend (Oct. 18/19) is our last
for the season.
(Then we hibernate).

Our 20%-50% SALE is extended
through this weekend.

Why is this man smiling? Because he scored himself an Oscar Peterson album ON SALE before The Mystery Spot hibernates fo...
10/14/2025

Why is this man smiling? Because he scored himself an Oscar Peterson album ON SALE before The Mystery Spot hibernates for the season. That’s right! This is our LAST weekend of the season - Sat/Sun Oct. 18/19.

Because we love our customers, our Columbus Weekend sale will be extended for one more weekend! 20% - 50%!

This is your last chance to shop The Spot until the spring* so come on down this weekend and join the ranks of Happy Customers!

*we hope to open holiday weekends, weather permitting

📸:DG

Bill Blass suede coat and skirt set - score!
10/13/2025

Bill Blass suede coat and skirt set - score!

Records and T-shirts, 20% off!
10/12/2025

Records and T-shirts, 20% off!

Another view of our kickass Record Room, where all vinyl is 20% off this Sunday and Monday!
10/11/2025

Another view of our kickass Record Room, where all vinyl is 20% off this Sunday and Monday!

The BIG SALE is here! All Columbus weekend The Mystery Spot’s megasale is ON: 20% - 50% off!20% off records!20% off vint...
10/10/2025

The BIG SALE is here! All Columbus weekend The Mystery Spot’s megasale is ON: 20% - 50% off!

20% off records!

20% off vintage clothing!

50% off all other vintage + antique items!

Open 11-5 this Saturday and Sunday
AND 10-2:30 Monday (Columbus Day)

Don’t forget, only one more weekend before we HIBERNATE FOR THE WINTER!

Mystery Spot Antiques, 72 Main Street, Phoenicia NY

#20-50%sale !

Address

72 Main Street
Phoenicia, NY
12464

Opening Hours

Saturday 11am - 5pm
Sunday 11am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mystery Spot Antiques posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mystery Spot Antiques:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Clutter My World

The Catskills' vintage odditorium in Phoenicia, NY. Now HIBERNATING for the winter. Check our posts now and then because we hope to occasionally pop open for a few holiday weekends over the winter (weather and mood dependent). Then we’ll re-open for our 19th season in Phoenicia sometime this spring!

This Catskills' "shrine to clutter" occupies seven packed-to-the-rafters rooms in a former 1800's Main Street hotel in Phoenicia, NY in the Catskill Mountains. Mystery Spot Antiques is home to an amazing array of vintage breakables, hand-picked vintage clothing, housewares, antiquarian art books, Rusticalia, mid-century lighting, tons of used records and found objects you won't find elsewhere, as well as anything else that catches artist/proprietress Laura Levine's honed eye. She regularly brings in fresh estate treasures, armfuls of killer estate-fresh vintage clothing, and stacks of vintage vinyl dug out of estate collections. For eighteen seasons the Mystery Spot has been the "must-see" destination for treasure hunters, thrifters, fashionistas, record diggers, tourists, musicians, curiosity seekers, fashion designers, prop stylists, and even a famous face or two. Even when the shop is not open, customers are welcome to dig through the dollar record bins and famous "Yard Sale in a Box" on the front porch, with an honor box/money drop at your service. Homer & Langley's Mystery Spot Antiques 72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464 (845) 688-7868 Please "like" this page, follow us on Instagram @MysterySpotAntiques or sign up for our mailing list and you'll be the first to know about upcoming sales and announcements.

http://www.mysteryspotantiques.com (website) http://www.mysteryspotvintage.com (blog) @mysteryspotantiques (Instagram) email: [email protected]